A comparison of civil law and moral law in sophocles play antigone
-antigone contrasts two types of law and justice: divine law and the law of men divine law vs human law ismens's weakness divine law vs human law in ancient greece divine law:-everything believed to be determined by fate-gods at the mercy of fate sophocles:-greek theater play writer in greece. Antigone: moral law vs political law in the theban play antigone one of the central themes is the fight between what the state finds to be immoral or wrong and what an individual believes is the right thing to do. Explain the dichotomy between civil law and moral or theological law how is this being addressed in the play creon is trying to enforce civil law while antigone wants to honor the gods by expressing moral/theological law.
Sophocles’ play antigone seems to confirm the superiority of natural law over positive (man-made) law the conflict and struggle between creon and antigone is an indication of the conflict that exists in the higher moral law- natural law, on one hand the man-made law on the other hand. Divine law is law that comes from a greater power than man, typically a type of god example 1 antigone and ismene argue about what comes first, the religous duty of citizens or the civil duty creon has declared that it's forbidden to bury the body of polynecies, this is an example of human law. To conclude, through the study of the play antigone, and the examination of the two critical articles, “antigone: kinship, justice, and the polis,” and “assumptions and the creation of meaning: reading sophocles’ antigone,” it is evident that few of the aspects of this play are divine law, kinship morality, and the rights of woman.
In the play antigone by sophocles, creon and antigone have distinct conflicting values creon's regard for the laws of the city causes him to abandon all other beliefs he feels that all should obey the laws set forth by him, even if other beliefs, moral or religious, state otherwise. In the play, antigone, antigone is finding it hard to distinguish between to follow her moral law or the civil law antigone doesn’t want to break the law but yet she wants to bury her brother polynices and give him a proper burial. In the play, antigone, antigone is finding it hard to distinguish between to follow her moral law or the civil law antigone doesn't want to break the law but yet she wants to bury her brother polynices and give him a proper burial. Noting that men live with too passive a regard for the moral laws, cited antigone as a stirring example of civil disobedience 5 by comparing sophocles's antigone, 6 written in fifth century bce athens, and jean.
Sophocles: antigone (reason and law) early in this play antigone has to decide whether to obey divine law and bury her brother polyneices or obey civil law and leave him unburied she publicly proclaims she will follow “the immortal unrecorded laws of god” rather than the mortal recorded laws of thebes. The major moral conflict in antigone by sophocles is the conflict over which value is most fundamental the play presents the moral conflict over whether the god’s law or the city’s law is more powerful this seems to be the most prominent theme the conflict arises mainly between the tragic. Sophocles then used other characters such as ismene, haemon and tiresias to show the public how valuable the principle of moral and the respect of the civil law were in the society of thebes moreover, demonstrates how the protagonist creon and antigone were confident on their point of view. - divine law versus human law sophocles' famous play, antigone, can be perceived as a conflict between individual conscience and state policy yet the issue of the play goes beyond that conflict and touches the universal conditions of suffering, religion, and loyalty. Antigone in the play antigone i have observed a variety of personality traits the character of antigone portrays antigone confronts king creon, although she is fully aware that he will sentence her to death as the ultimate punishment for disobeying his law.
Antigone chose to attribute herself with moral law instead of creon’s rash and destructive civil law antigone felt that no one had [ ] written law v moral law an analysis of antigone by sophocles moreover it appeared that antigone believed that death tied with moral pleasure far outweighed that of having life while exercising obedience to. Antigone vs natural law theory antigone vs creon: struggles, beliefs, and morals antigone vs creon: struggles, beliefs, and morals in sophocles’ play, antigone, creon and his young niece antigone encounter many struggles in their lives because of moral views and political laws. Family versus law in antigone one of the central questions of antigone has to do with how a person in the world of the play is obligated to both family and law at the start of the play. Socrates and antigone comparison search this site socrates and antigone socrates and antigone have a lot in common in terms of their civil disobedience and their willingness to die in order to spread their message socrates is a celebrated greek philosopher while antigone is a fictional character created by another greek, a poet in the. Fate, loyalty, and law in antigone the play antigone by sophocles is a play like no other there are three major themes or ideas which have a very important role in the play the first major theme is fate, on how the play comes about and the turn of events that come about throughout it.
A comparison of civil law and moral law in sophocles play antigone
Antigone’s moral dilemma margaret walsh south university online antigone’s moral dilemma perhaps the most pronounced question in the play antigone by sophocles' is the value of human law vs divine law. Compare and contrast log in × scroll to top home antigone's choice between the civil and moral law in antigone by sophocles pages 2 words 378 view full essay more essays like this: sophocles, antigone, civil law vs moral law sophocles, antigone, civil law vs moral law not sure what i'd do without @kibin - alfredo alvarez, student. Antigone vs creon: struggles, beliefs, and morals antigone vs creon: struggles, beliefs, and morals in sophocles’ play, antigone, creon and his young niece antigone encounter many struggles in their lives because of moral views and political laws.
“antigone” is a tragedy by the ancient greek playwright sophocles, written around 442 bcealthough it was written before sophocles’ other two theban plays, chronologically it comes after the stories in “oedipus the king” and “oedipus at colonus”, and it picks up where aeschylus' play “seven against thebes” ends it deals with antigone’s burial of her brother polynices. The short play, antigone, was written in 441 bc by the greek playwright sophocles it deals with some of the most basic problems that affect a society one of them is civil disobedience. To antigone, these outweigh any human laws in antigone , sophocles explores this tension and seems to suggest—through antigone's martyrdom, the people's sympathy, and creon's downfall—that the laws of the state should not contradict natural laws.
The play entitled antigone was written by a man named sophocles, a scholarly author of philosophy and logic the play antigone is probably one of the most prominent interpretations of a tragic drama. Creon says that the laws enacted by the leader of the city must be obeyed, large and small, / right and wrong in other words, creon is arguing that the law is the basis for justice, so there can be no such thing as an unjust law antigone, on the other hand, believes that there are unjust laws, and that she has a moral duty to disobey a law that contradicts what she thinks. Moral law vs political law in sophocles’ antigone essay 979 words | 4 pages believes in, no matter what the price is in sophocles’ antigone, a written dramatic play, sophocles portrays the theme that at times of one’s life, it is necessary to follow moral law and ignore political law. A summary of antigone, lines 1–416 in sophocles's the oedipus plays learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of the oedipus plays and what it means perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans.